Third-Party Administrator Benchmarking Study, 2027

    Sherlock Company has benchmarked health plan administrative costs for more than 30 years and has included third-party administrators since 2010. The 2027 study measures administrative cost by function, using calendar 2026 data. There is no fee to take part, and we can complete the survey form for you.

    Results of the most recent TPA study, in Plan Management Navigator

    The 2027 Study

    What the study measures
    Administrative cost by function, per member per month and per employee per month
    Drivers reported
    Staffing, compensation, non-labor costs and outsourcing
    Compared against
    Other TPAs, and Blue Cross and independent health plan ASO business
    Data year
    Calendar 2026
    Study opens
    March 1, 2027
    Submissions due
    July 30, 2027
    Participation fee
    None for 2027

    What the Study Measures

    The study measures administrative cost for each function, from claims and customer service to information systems and sales. Each function is defined in the Guidelines, so every firm reports its costs the same way.

    Costs are reported per member per month and per employee per month, for medical and dental products. For each function the study also reports staffing, compensation, non-labor costs and outsourcing, which explain why one firm’s cost differs from another’s.

    Blue Cross Blue Shield and independent health plans report their ASO business to us in the same way, so a TPA’s results can be compared with theirs as well as with other TPAs.

    The Most Recent Study

    The most recent TPA study was published in March 2026 and used calendar 2024 data. Five administrators serving 1.1 million members took part. As Figure 1 shows, their median administrative cost for medical products was $18.52 per member per month, lower than the medians for the ASO business of health plans.

    Figure 1


    Administrative Cost of Medical Products

    Medians per member per month, calendar 2024

    UniverseCost PMPM
    Third-Party Administrators$18.52
    Independent / Provider-Sponsored Plans, ASO$24.20
    Blue Cross Blue Shield Plans, ASO/ASC$27.03

    Source: Plan Management Navigator, Late March 2026.

    Account and Membership Administration is key to understanding the difference. For that group of functions, the median cost of Blue Plans was 53.8% above the TPA median, and that of Independent / Provider-Sponsored Plans was 27.5% above. Its largest component is Information Systems, where the Blue Plan median was 161.0% above the TPA median and the Independent / Provider-Sponsored median was 136.9% above.

    What You Receive

    Each participant receives the report of the study, with its own figures beside those of the group. The most recent report contained the sections below. We are rebuilding the study for 2027 with the advice of TPAs, so the contents may change.

    • •
      Functional expenses per member per month, per employee per month, per group per month and as a percent of revenue, for medical and dental products
    • •
      Expenses of comparable services at Blue Cross Blue Shield and Independent / Provider-Sponsored Plans
    • •
      Staffing ratios, compensation and propensity to outsource
    • •
      Operational metrics
    • •
      Characteristics of the participants as a group, including membership, product mix, groups served and revenues

    Table of contents of the 2025 Third-Party Administrator Edition (PDF)

    We will walk you through your results if you would like.

    How It Works

    You can complete the survey form yourselves, or we can complete it for you.

    1. 1.
      We start with a 20-minute call. Before it, we send the Guidelines under a mutual confidentiality agreement.
    2. 2.
      The survey form is completed between March 1 and July 30, 2027. If we complete it, you send us three files: your trial balance, headcount and membership. If your team completes it, the Guidelines define every function and line, and we are available by phone while you work through it.
    3. 3.
      You review and approve the completed form. We check each submission for outliers and ask you to verify anything unusual.
    4. 4.
      You receive the report, with your figures beside those of other TPAs and of health plan ASO business.

    Confidentiality

    Your data is confidential. Results are reported for the group, and no participant is named in the results or anywhere else.

    Questions

    How much of our time does it take?

    If we complete the form, your part is sending the three files, answering a few questions and approving the completed form. If your team completes it, the Guidelines walk through every line.

    What if we do not track costs by product line?

    Many administrators do not. The Guidelines explain how to allocate shared costs, and we can work through it with you on a call.

    Can we license the results without taking part?

    Yes. The results of the study will be available to license. Contact us for details.

    Contact

    Send this form to request the Guidelines or arrange a call.

    How can we help? *

    You can also reach Andrew Sherlock directly.

    Andrew L. Sherlock
    Health Care Analyst
    Sherlock Company
    P.O. Box 444
    Gwynedd Valley, PA 19437

    asherlock@sherlockco.com
    Phone: 215-628-2289

    Subscribe and receive insights into the metrics and trends shaping health plan performance.