Dental Benchmarking Study, 2027
Sherlock Company has benchmarked health plan administrative costs for more than 30 years. For 2027 we are building a Dental Edition, using calendar 2026 data. Trade sources publish dental enrollment, premium and claims processing figures, but no one publishes what it costs to administer a dental plan, function by function. There is no fee to take part, and we can complete the survey form for you.
The 2027 Study
- What the study measures
- Administrative cost by function, per member per month
- Reported separately
- Insured and administered business, and PPO, DHMO and indemnity plans
- Drivers reported
- Staffing, compensation, non-labor costs and outsourcing
- Data year
- Calendar 2026
- Guidelines
- Drafted, covering 17 functions
- Schedule
- Confirmed with each participant
- Participation fee
- None for 2027
What the Study Measures
The study measures administrative cost for each function, from claims and customer service to information systems and sales. The Guidelines, now in draft, define 17 functions line by line, so every organization reports its costs the same way.
Costs are reported per member per month. Insured and administered business are reported separately, and so are PPO, DHMO and indemnity plans. For each function the study also reports staffing, compensation, non-labor costs and outsourcing.
Our health plan studies already include stand-alone dental products. In 2025, the Blue Cross Blue Shield Plans in our study served 8.3 million stand-alone dental members, at an administrative cost of $3.26 per member per month, or 17.4% of premium (Plan Management Navigator, June 2026). The Dental Edition measures dental plans and administrators in more detail.
What You Receive
Each participant receives the results of the study, with its own figures beside those of the group:
- •Administrative cost by function, per member per month
- •Insured and administered business, and PPO, DHMO and indemnity plans, each shown separately
- •Staffing and compensation by function
- •A walkthrough of your results, if you would like one
How It Works
You can complete the survey form yourselves, or we can complete it for you. The calendar is confirmed with each participant.
- 1.We start with a 20-minute call. Before it, we send the Guidelines under a mutual confidentiality agreement.
- 2.The survey form is completed. If we complete it, you send us three files: your trial balance, headcount and membership. If your team completes it, the Guidelines define every function and line, and we are available by phone while you work through it.
- 3.You review and approve the completed form.
- 4.You receive the results, with your figures beside those of other dental plans.
Confidentiality
Your data is confidential. Results are reported for the group, and no participant is named in the results or anywhere else.
Questions
Our dental business sits inside a larger carrier. Can we take part?
Yes. Tell us how your dental business is organized, and we will work through with you how its costs are reported.
How much of our time does it take?
If we complete the form, your part is sending the three files, answering a few questions and approving the completed form. If your team completes it, the Guidelines walk through every line.
What if we do not track costs the way the form asks?
Most organizations do not at first. The Guidelines explain how to allocate shared costs, and we can work through it with you on a call.
Can we license the results without taking part?
Yes. The results of the study will be available to license. Contact us for details.
Contact
You can also reach Andrew Sherlock directly.
Andrew L. Sherlock
Health Care Analyst
Sherlock Company
P.O. Box 444
Gwynedd Valley, PA 19437